About Sierra Rutherford

Sierra Rutherford Guelph, ON Real Estate Agent Headshot

Agent Details

Meet Sierra

Born and raised in Guelph, Ontario and a UoG Bachelor of Commerce graduate, I’ve always had a deep connection to this community. I’ve experienced life in 8 different neighbourhoods and a variety of homes - from charming century properties to modern new builds. Each move gave me a unique perspective on what makes living in Guelph so special.

I started my real estate career in 2015 as Andra Arnold’s marketing and administrative coordinator, and in 2021 I became a licensed REALTOR®. Over the years, I’ve supported hundreds of clients and transactions, each one a unique experience. Watching Andra’s business grow has been incredible, and I’m grateful to have played a part in building something that helps so many families find their place in Guelph.
 
Outside of real estate, I’ve always been passionate about community and connection. Growing up, I played basketball for the Guelph CYO Knights and St. James CHS, and later coached with Shake True Hoops. Travel is another love of mine - I’ve been lucky enough to explore 25 countries and counting, learning from different cultures and gaining a fresh appreciation for why Guelph will always feel like home.
 
If you’re looking to buy or sell in Guelph, Wellington County, or Waterloo Region, I’d be so grateful to assist you. Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer, moving up, downsizing, or investing, I’m here to make your real estate journey smooth and stress-free.

What our clients say

Salim S.

Salim S.

Without a doubt, the most fantastic realtor that I have ever dealt with. Personable, knowledgeable, and a very good advisor. She sold our house (in this market!) faster than I could have ever hoped, after a couple of failed att...
Read Client Reviews
Joanna S.

Joanna S.

From my first call with Andra, I knew I was in good hands. Andra was so helpful from beginning to end. She went above and beyond anything I would have expected and always had my best interests in mind. Told her my criteria for ...
Read Client Reviews
Maria J.

Maria J.

We would highly recommend Andra Arnold & Associates. Our agent Nina went above and beyond to help us find the right home.
Read Client Reviews
Brad F.

Brad F.

We made the right decision choosing Andra and her team to sell our home. She was extremely professional and went above and beyond our expectations throughout the entire process. In a tough market, Andra came in with a strong, s...
Read Client Reviews
Niki C.

Niki C.

Andra and her team are the best. They are professional but, more importantly, they are warm, engaging, and trustworthy.
Read Client Reviews
Vincent C.

Vincent C.

Very knowledgeable of her market, in less than 2 weeks of research, we found the house that we ultimately bought. Efficiency and reliability. Top-tier agent.
Read Client Reviews
Janice O.

Janice O.

We had a wonderful experience dealing with Kristin Dipietro and Meghan Grieve in the selling of our home and in finding a new place to call our own. Kristin professionally guided us through the process of listing our home in a ...
Read Client Reviews
Joanne S.

Joanne S.

We have been working with Andra for a few years, trying to decide if we would move or stay in our house. In September, we were offered a unit in the Arboretum and decided that we would downsize and sell our home. We did not lis...
Read Client Reviews
Ken P.

Ken P.

Andra and her team are very competent professionals who truly understand the housing market and will work with you to provide maximum value on the sale of your home. Andra's team has assisted my aging father and father-in-law i...
Read Client Reviews
Sly C.

Sly C.

Working with Andra was truly exceptional from start to finish. Throughout the entire process, we felt not just supported but genuinely cared for. I am likely one of the more particular clients she’s worked with, yet I always fe...
Read Client Reviews
T. F.

T. F.

We met with Andra, and she understood immediately what our needs and goals were. Her expertise and kindness were so appreciated from the beginning of our purchase to the end of our sale. She and her team worked diligently and t...
Read Client Reviews
Pamela

Pamela

Andra Arnold and her team were the very best realtors for all steps of selling the house. They strategized on price, gave recommendations on the best date to list, staged the house to make it look its best, had professional pho...
Read Client Reviews
Mateus Pies G.

Mateus Pies G.

Our family had an excellent experience with Andra Arnold & Associates, and especially with Sierra Rutherford, who directly assisted us throughout our rental search in Guelph. We were relocating from another country for a one-ye...
Read Client Reviews
Tathyane G.

Tathyane G.

We had a very good experience with Andra Arnold & Associates, especially with Sierra Rutherford, who helped our family find a rental home in Guelph while we were still abroad. We were moving from Brazil with three children, and...
Read Client Reviews
Karen M.

Karen M.

Thank you to Andra and her team, who make the process effortless. Client care is always prioritized when you work with Andra Arnold & Associates.
Read Client Reviews
Deb P.

Deb P.

Andra is an amazing person and a great realtor! We have sold two houses now with Andra and highly recommend her and her team! Fantastic service, great communication, and she works very hard to provide the best for you!
Read Client Reviews
Molly G.

Molly G.

Andra was easy to communicate with and always quick to respond. The entire process was smooth, well-organized, and handled professionally from start to finish.
Read Client Reviews
Olivia J.

Olivia J.

We worked with Meghan from Andra's team. Meghan was super great to work with, super informative, friendly, and quick to answer any of our questions! Highly recommend working with her.
Read Client Reviews
Hailey K.

Hailey K.

My partner and I worked with Meghan Grieve to find a rental property, and she was so kind and helpful. She didn't mind when we were picky, and she showed us houses rain or shine! We will definitely look to work with her again i...
Read Client Reviews
Tanya B.

Tanya B.

Andra and the team were amazing to work with from the first interaction to the final sale of the house. They were very professional, knowledgeable, and staged the house to perfection. It sold in 3 days!
Read Client Reviews

Featured listings

For Sale
For Lease

Start your property search

Browse Homes

Let's start the conversation

Whether you have a question about a listing, want to discuss your home's value, or simply aren't sure where to begin — we're here. Reach out and a member of our team will get back to you promptly!

Follow along on Instagram